WWE NXT delivered an action-packed episode on May 5, 2026, with a mix of thrilling matches and underwhelming moments. In this review, we’ll dive into the best and worst of the night, highlighting the highs and lows of the broadcast.
3 Things We Hated
1. The Overhyped Main Event
The main event of the evening, a Fatal 4-Way match for the NXT Championship, left a lot to be desired. The match was marred by poor timing, awkward moments, and a storyline that felt forced. The lack of cohesion and coherence in the match made it difficult for viewers to become invested in the action unfolding on screen.
According to a WWE insider, the creative team had initially envisioned a more straightforward and focused match, but changes in the storyline and sudden injuries to key participants led to a rushed and disjointed product.
“The main event was a mess,” the insider stated. “We had a great concept, but it got lost in translation. The guys in the ring did their best with what they were given, but it was clear that they were working with a lot of last-minute changes. It’s not an excuse, but it’s the reality of what happened behind the scenes.”
2. Underwhelming Tag Team Action
The tag team match between The D’Angelo Family and The New Day felt like a missed opportunity. With two teams boasting incredible chemistry and charisma, the match fell flat due to poor pacing and an unengaging storyline. The crowd, which was electric for the majority of the episode, seemed disinterested in this particular contest.
A source close to The New Day revealed that the team was disappointed with the outcome of their match, feeling that it didn’t showcase their strengths and talents as well as it could have.
“We’re a team that thrives on energy and excitement,” the source said. “Unfortunately, this match didn’t have the same spark that we’re used to. We’re still proud of what we accomplished in the ring, but we know we can do better.”
3. Lack of Resolution on Key Storylines
A number of storylines on NXT have been building momentum for weeks, but the May 5 episode failed to provide any substantial updates or resolutions. The ongoing feud between Roxanne Perez and Kiana James, for example, was glossed over in favor of a brief, inconclusive segment.
A WWE insider noted that the creative team is aware of the need to advance these storylines but acknowledges the challenges of balancing multiple narratives.
“There are a lot of moving parts in NXT, and it’s not always easy to give each storyline the attention it deserves,” the insider said. “We’re working hard to make sure that every episode feels cohesive and engaging, but sometimes we have to make tough decisions about what to prioritize.”
3 Things We Loved
1. Thrilling Match Between Io Shirai and Zoey Stark
The women’s match between Io Shirai and Zoey Stark was an instant classic, showcasing the incredible athleticism and in-ring skills of both competitors. The match was a masterclass in storytelling, with each woman bringing their unique style and personality to the table.
Shirai’s submission moves and Stark’s high-flying acrobatics made for a thrilling combination that left the crowd on the edge of their seats. The chemistry between the two women was palpable, and their post-match interaction hinted at a potential future rivalry.
According to a source close to Shirai, the wrestler was thrilled with the outcome of the match and is eager to face Stark again in the near future.
“Io was in her element tonight,” the source said. “She and Zoey have a natural chemistry that makes their matches must-see TV. We’re hoping to see more of them in the ring together soon.”
2. Impressive Debut of New Talent
The debut of newcomer Jake Atlas was a highlight of the evening, showcasing the wrestler’s impressive in-ring skills and charismatic personality. Atlas’s match against Bronson Matthews was a solid effort, with the young talent displaying a natural ability to connect with the crowd.
A source close to Atlas revealed that the wrestler has been training for years and is eager to prove himself as a top contender in NXT.
“Jake has been working tirelessly to hone his craft,” the source said. “He’s determined to make a name for himself in NXT and prove that he belongs among the best in the world.”
3. Emotional Moment Between Cameron Grimes and Tyler Bate
The segment between Cameron Grimes and Tyler Bate was an emotional highlight of the evening, showcasing the deep connection between the two wrestlers. Grimes’s heartfelt words and Bate’s genuine response made for a poignant moment that resonated with the audience.
According to a source close to Grimes, the wrestler was moved by the experience and is grateful for the opportunity to share his feelings with Bate.
“Cameron is a talented wrestler with a lot of heart,” the source said. “He’s been working on his character and is eager to showcase his emotional side in the ring. This moment was a great opportunity for him to connect with the audience on a deeper level.”
In conclusion, the May 5 episode of WWE NXT was a mixed bag, with both highs and lows. While the main event fell flat and some storylines were left unresolved, the show still managed to deliver some thrilling moments, including an outstanding match between Io Shirai and Zoey Stark and the impressive debut of Jake Atlas.