WWE fans have been eagerly awaiting news on the recovery of Zoey Stark, and now, fresh updates suggest that the company is not only optimistic about her return but also preparing a major character shift for the rising star. According to multiple reports, Stark is targeting a mid-2026 in-ring comeback, with WWE officials reportedly “still very high on her” and already mapping out her next chapter.
Stark’s Injury and Recovery Timeline
Zoey Stark’s career took a sudden turn in May 2025 when she suffered a devastating knee injury during a Money in the Bank qualifying match on Monday Night RAW. The bout, a triple threat against Rhea Ripley and Kairi Sane, saw Stark attempt a springboard dropkick from the middle rope. Unfortunately, she landed awkwardly, immediately signaling something was wrong. She was quickly removed from the match, and it was later confirmed that she had torn her ACL, MCL, and meniscus.
Stark underwent a three-hour surgery at Rothman Orthopaedics in Orlando, followed by months of intensive rehabilitation. The initial prognosis was that she could be sidelined for the remainder of 2025, but the severity of her injuries has pushed her projected return window into the middle of 2026.
Despite the setback, Stark has remained active on social media, sharing updates about her recovery. In a recent Instagram post, she revealed that she faced a difficult phase in rehab, with doctors warning she might need a knee scope or manipulation under anesthesia due to limited mobility. “It’s been both mentally and physically exhausting and frustrating,” Stark admitted in August. “But I will push through this. I will find a way around it. I’ll get to where I need to get.”
WWE’s Big Plans for Stark’s Comeback
While Stark’s absence has been felt on the main roster, WWE’s creative team has been busy discussing her future direction. According to sources close to the situation, the company is considering a major character shift for Stark upon her return: a babyface turn.
This would mark a significant change for the 27-year-old star, who has primarily portrayed a heel throughout her main roster tenure. Stark first gained attention as a heel alongside WWE Hall of Famer Trish Stratus, later aligning with Shayna Baszler and Sonya Deville in the Pure Fusion Collective. After the group disbanded earlier this year, Stark was poised for a singles run before her injury.
“WWE is still very high on Zoey,” said a WWE insider familiar with the discussions. “They see her as a future main eventer, and they want her return to be impactful. A babyface turn could be the perfect way to reintroduce her to the audience and set her up for bigger opportunities down the line.”
A Fresh Start for a Rising Star
Stark’s potential babyface turn would not only be a new direction for her but also a strategic move for WWE. With both Baszler and Deville no longer with the company, Stark will need to be repackaged as a singles competitor. A fresh, heroic persona could help her connect with fans in a new way and position her as a top contender in the women’s division.
“Zoey has always been a fan favorite in NXT, and her in-ring ability is undeniable,” the insider added. “This could be her chance to finally break through as a main roster star. WWE is looking at her as a long-term investment, and they want her return to be memorable.”
Stark’s journey in WWE has been marked by resilience and determination. Signed in 2021, she quickly made a name for herself in NXT, winning the NXT Women’s Tag Team Championship with partner Rhea Ripley. Her transition to the main roster in 2023 was met with high expectations, and despite setbacks, she has remained a key figure in WWE’s women’s division.
What’s Next for Zoey Stark?
As Stark continues her recovery, WWE is reportedly keeping her involved behind the scenes, ensuring she stays connected to the company and its creative process. The mid-2026 return window gives her ample time to heal and prepare for her next chapter.
“Zoey’s work ethic and attitude have impressed everyone in the locker room,” the insider said. “She’s not just a talented performer; she’s a true professional. When she comes back, she’s going to be ready to make a big impact.”
For fans, Stark’s return could signal a new era for the women’s division. With WWE’s continued focus on elevating new talent, a healthy and motivated Stark could be the catalyst for fresh storylines and rivalries.
Conclusion
Zoey Stark’s journey from injury to recovery has been a testament to her resilience and dedication. As WWE prepares for her mid-2026 return, the company is setting the stage for a major character shift that could redefine her career. With big plans in place and a babyface turn on the horizon, Stark’s comeback could be one of the most anticipated moments in WWE history.
Stay tuned for more updates as Zoey Stark continues her path back to the ring, ready to make her mark on the main roster once again.