WWE fans have seen their fair share of General Managers over the years, from the legendary Eric Bischoff to the unpredictable Vickie Guerrero. But according to WWE Hall of Famer Mickie James, her husband Nick Aldis is now being mentioned in the same breath as some of the most iconic figures to ever hold the position—especially when it comes to the blue brand, SmackDown.
James recently made headlines with her bold claim that Aldis, who currently serves as SmackDown’s General Manager, could be considered one of the best GMs in the history of the show. Her comments have sparked debate among fans and insiders alike, especially as Aldis continues to make waves behind the scenes and occasionally in front of the camera.
Aldis’ Rise to SmackDown Authority
Nick Aldis, a two-time NWA World Heavyweight Champion and veteran of promotions like New Japan Pro Wrestling and Pro Wrestling NOAH, signed with WWE in August 2023. Initially brought in as a backstage producer, Aldis quickly earned the trust of WWE executives and was soon elevated to the role of SmackDown General Manager.
His transition from in-ring competitor to authority figure has been seamless, with many praising his ability to balance fairness, drama, and long-term storytelling. Aldis’ background as a respected veteran has given him credibility with both the locker room and the audience, and his leadership has helped shape some of SmackDown’s most memorable moments in recent months.
According to a WWE insider, “Nick brings a unique blend of old-school professionalism and modern sensibilities. He’s not just a figurehead—he’s actively involved in creative discussions and genuinely cares about the product.”
Mickie James: “Nick Aldis Is Possibly the Best GM Ever”
Mickie James, herself a five-time WWE Women’s Champion and Hall of Famer, has been vocal in her support of her husband’s work. In a recent interview, she didn’t hold back when asked about Aldis’ impact on SmackDown.
“I think Nick is possibly the best General Manager of all time,” James said. “He’s brought a level of integrity and excitement to the role that we haven’t seen in a long time. He’s not just there to read scripts—he’s shaping the show, making tough decisions, and standing up for what’s right.”
James went on to compare Aldis to some of the most beloved GMs in WWE history, including Theodore Long and Vickie Guerrero. “When you look at what Nick’s done in such a short time, it’s really impressive. He’s got that same energy, that same passion. He’s not afraid to make bold moves, but he also knows when to step back and let the talent shine.”
The Aldis Effect: What Makes Him Different?
So what sets Nick Aldis apart from other General Managers? According to sources close to the SmackDown production team, it’s his hands-on approach and deep understanding of the wrestling business.
“Nick isn’t just a suit,” said a SmackDown writer who requested anonymity. “He’s been in the ring, he’s been a champion, he’s worked all over the world. When he makes a decision, it’s not just about ratings or storylines—it’s about what’s best for the wrestlers and the fans.”
Aldis has also been praised for his ability to connect with the roster. Unlike some GMs who are seen as distant or out of touch, Aldis is known for being approachable and fair. Wrestlers appreciate that he listens to their ideas and is willing to collaborate on creative direction.
“He’s not afraid to take risks,” said a mid-card SmackDown star. “He’s given us opportunities we wouldn’t have gotten otherwise. He’s also not afraid to stand up to management when he thinks something’s wrong. That earns respect.”
Could Aldis Return to the Ring?
While Aldis has found success as a GM, many fans—and even some insiders—wonder if he’s done with in-ring competition. After all, he’s only 41 years old and still in excellent shape.
Mickie James believes her husband is “far from done” as a wrestler. “If the right opportunity came along, I know he’d jump at the chance to lace up his boots again,” she said. “He’s got so much left to give, and I think fans would love to see him back in action.”
According to a WWE source, there’s been “quiet discussion” about a potential in-ring return for Aldis, possibly at a major event like WrestleMania or SummerSlam. “It would be a huge moment,” the source said. “Nick’s got the respect of the locker room, and fans would eat it up. But it would have to be the right story, the right opponent.”
Aldis vs. Bischoff: The Ultimate GM Debate
James’ comments have reignited the debate over who the greatest SmackDown GM of all time really is. While Eric Bischoff is often cited as the gold standard—thanks to his controversial decisions and larger-than-life personality—Aldis is quickly making a case for himself.
“Bischoff was great because he was unpredictable and always stirring the pot,” said James. “But Nick brings something different. He’s steady, he’s fair, and he’s got that old-school wrestling credibility. I think he’s on the same level.”
Some fans argue that Aldis’ impact is still too new to judge, while others believe he’s already surpassed some of his predecessors. “Nick’s only been GM for a year, but he’s already made a bigger impact than some guys did in five,” said a longtime SmackDown viewer. “He’s got the respect of the fans and the roster. That’s rare.”
The Future of SmackDown Under Aldis
As SmackDown continues to evolve, Nick Aldis’ role as General Manager will likely become even more important. With the brand facing stiff competition from Raw and NXT, Aldis’ leadership could be the key to keeping SmackDown relevant and exciting.
“Nick’s got a vision for where SmackDown should go,” said a WWE executive who spoke on background. “He’s not just maintaining the status quo—he’s pushing the brand forward. That’s what we need right now.”
Whether or not Aldis is truly the best GM in SmackDown history, one thing is clear: he’s making his mark, and fans are taking notice. With Mickie James in his corner and the support of the locker room behind him, Nick Aldis is proving that he’s more than just a former champion—he’s a leader.
And if James has her way, her husband’s legacy as a GM will be remembered alongside the very best the business has ever seen.