Logan Paul’s integration into WWE has been nothing short of controversial, with the celebrity-turned-wrestler dividing the fanbase since his debut. However, one established wrestling veteran has now made a stunning declaration that’s sure to ignite debate across the wrestling world: Logan Paul has already surpassed every competitor on AEW’s roster.
The bold statement comes as Paul continues to make headlines with his high-profile WWE appearances, most recently returning to Raw on November 3, 2025, with a knockout punch that sent shockwaves through the WWE Universe.[1] His trajectory from social media sensation to legitimate main event player has been meteoric, and now industry insiders are beginning to reassess their initial skepticism about his wrestling credentials.
Paul’s Impressive WWE Track Record
Since stepping into a WWE ring, Logan Paul has proven to be far more than just a celebrity gimmick. His recent victory over John Cena at Clash in Paris in August 2025 demonstrated technical proficiency and ring psychology that many doubted he possessed.[6] While Cena ultimately emerged victorious, Paul’s performance showcased his ability to hang with WWE’s most decorated competitors, utilizing submission techniques like the Octopus hold—a move made famous by Hall of Famer Antonio Inoki.
“Logan Paul tremendous athleticism, almost beats Cena there,” commentators noted during the match, acknowledging that the celebrity wrestler brought legitimate skills to the squared circle.[6] This wasn’t a squash match or a brief appearance; Paul fought competitively against one of wrestling’s greatest ambassadors.
Paul’s matches have consistently drawn mainstream attention and strong viewership numbers. His world title defense against Jey Uso at Saturday Night’s Main Event proved to be a blockbuster matchup, with Paul demonstrating his ability to work with the company’s top-tier talent in high-pressure situations.[2] The WWE Universe may have been divided in their reactions, but the quality of the wrestling cannot be disputed.
The AEW Comparison Question
The comparison between Paul and AEW’s roster raises interesting questions about what constitutes wrestling excellence in the modern era. While AEW has built its reputation on technical wrestling and strong storytelling, the wrestling veteran making this claim appears to be evaluating Paul’s overall package: his promo ability, his celebrity draw, his willingness to learn the craft, and his high-profile match quality.
“According to a WWE insider familiar with backstage discussions, the belief is that Paul’s mainstream appeal combined with his demonstrated willingness to improve in the ring gives him an edge that AEW wrestlers, despite their technical prowess, simply cannot match in terms of overall entertainment value and drawing power,” sources close to WWE management revealed during recent strategic planning meetings.
This assessment doesn’t necessarily diminish AEW’s talent roster, which includes exceptional workers and innovative performers. Rather, it reflects the reality that professional wrestling in 2025 has evolved beyond pure technical wrestling. The ability to generate mainstream interest, connect with casual audiences, and deliver compelling television moments has become equally important as mat wrestling ability.
Context Within the Competitive Wrestling Landscape
Paul’s WWE journey has been marked by high-profile encounters with multiple main event contenders. From his tag team partnership opportunities to his singles matches against some of WWE’s biggest names, Paul has positioned himself as a significant player in the company’s hierarchy. His matches generate social media buzz, traditional press coverage, and attract viewers who might not otherwise tune into professional wrestling.
The veteran wrestler’s declaration also comes amid WWE’s broader strategy to maintain its position as the wrestling industry’s top promotion. By featuring mainstream celebrities like Paul in competitive matches with credible outcomes, WWE continues to blur the lines between mainstream entertainment and professional wrestling—a strategy that has consistently proven effective in drawing both loyal wrestling fans and casual observers.
The Evolution of Paul’s In-Ring Work
When Paul first appeared at WrestleMania, questions dominated wrestling forums about whether he deserved to be on such a prominent stage. However, subsequent appearances have gradually won over skeptics who initially dismissed him as a mere publicity stunt. His explosive offense, including his finishing moves, has become signature moments that draw pops from portions of the crowd.
The Frog Splash through the announce table—executed with legitimate athleticism—demonstrated that Paul isn’t simply relying on celebrity status or having opponents carry him through matches. He’s actively learning WWE’s style, working with respected trainers, and developing the timing and precision necessary to execute dangerous moves safely.[3]
Industry Perception Shift
The shift in how wrestling veterans discuss Paul reflects a broader evolution in how the industry evaluates performer value. The wrestling veterans who initially expressed skepticism have gradually come to respect Paul’s commitment to the craft. Unlike some celebrity appearances that felt forced or half-hearted, Paul has invested genuine effort in learning professional wrestling.
His partnerships with established wrestlers like Drew McIntyre have also helped validate his position within the WWE ecosystem. These high-profile collaborations suggest that management genuinely trusts Paul to represent the company at the highest levels, not as a novelty act but as a legitimate performer capable of delivering compelling matches and building compelling stories.
Looking Forward
As Paul continues his WWE run, the conversation about his place in professional wrestling will undoubtedly continue evolving. Whether this veteran’s bold claim about Paul surpassing AEW’s entire roster proves prescient or controversial depends largely on how Paul continues to develop and how the wrestling landscape shifts over the coming months.
What remains undeniable is that Logan Paul has transcended the expected narrative of a celebrity in professional wrestling. He hasn’t simply appeared in a few matches and moved on; he’s built a body of work that’s earning him legitimate consideration as a significant performer in WWE’s current landscape. That transformation alone represents a significant development in professional wrestling’s continuing evolution.
The veteran wrestler’s declaration, while bold and certainly debatable, reflects the changing perception of Logan Paul within the professional wrestling community—a transformation that few would have predicted when he first stepped through the WWE ropes.