Joe Hendry has once again combined his wrestling chops with musical wit by releasing a parody of Don McLean’s iconic “American Pie,” playfully mocking WWE NXT’s reigning AAA Mixed Tag Team Champions Ethan Page and Chelsea Green. The parody song comes hot on the heels of a memorable WWE NXT segment where Hendry, alongside Thea Hail, launched a pie-filled ambush during Page and Green’s championship celebration[1][2].
From Pie Chaos to Parody Hit: The Backstory
The saga began on a recent episode of WWE NXT when Ethan Page and Chelsea Green marked their AAA Mixed Tag Team Championship win with a festive cake-cutting celebration. However, the party turned sour as Joe Hendry stormed the scene demanding his title opportunity. In a surprise moment, Thea Hail emerged from the giant cake and splattered pie over Chelsea Green and Alba Fyre, with Hendry himself hitting Page with a pie as well[2].
This unexpected pie attack ignited a viral reaction, particularly due to Chelsea Green’s animated backstage rant. During her outburst, she exclaimed, “I have never been creamed on like this before,” a line that quickly became a popular meme across social media platforms[2]. Capitalizing on this buzz, Hendry crafted a parody song humorously chronicling the incident and targeting both Page and Green for their roles in the NXT storyline.
“Ethan and Chelsea Got Pied”: Lyrics with a Sharp Edge
Joe Hendry’s parody track, titled “Ethan and Chelsea Got Pied,” cleverly modifies the original “American Pie” lyrics to highlight the comedic fallout from the pie attack. In the song, Hendry brands Ethan Page a “disgrace” for his actions, while taking a risqué jab at Chelsea Green with the lyric, “Chelsea got pie, says she’s never been creamed, but that is a lie.” The parody even references Green’s husband Matt Cardona, underlining the eyebrow-raising dynamic: “Ethan Page is with her most of the time, but Matt Cardona says that it’s fine”[1].
The parody blends humor and wrestling drama, reinforcing Hendry’s reputation not only as a skilled wrestler but also as an entertainer who can leverage viral moments to amplify storylines.
Upcoming Showdowns: NXT Gold Rush Title Match
The timing of Hendry’s parody release is significant— it precedes a high-profile showdown at WWE NXT Gold Rush. Scheduled for November 18 and 25 at The Theater at Madison Square Garden in New York, Joe Hendry and Thea Hail will challenge Ethan Page and Chelsea Green for the AAA Mixed Tag Team Titles[1].
The stakes are high: Page entered this match period as a double champion after securing both the NXT North American Championship and AAA Mixed Tag Team Championship. Chelsea Green also became a double champion by winning on WWE SmackDown earlier in November 2025. Hendry aims to end Page and Green’s dominant run and reclaim championship glory, using every angle—including musical mockery—to gain the upper hand[1].
Insider Insights: WWE Backstage Buzz
According to a WWE insider familiar with the creative direction, “Joe Hendry’s parody is more than just a funny moment — it’s a strategic move. The WWE creative team loves when wrestlers bring their unique personal talents into storylines, and Hendry’s ability to turn a viral incident into a musical parody gives fans something fresh and memorable. It keeps NXT interesting and adds layers to the rivalry with Ethan and Chelsea.” The source adds, “This also lets Hendry generate buzz outside the ring, which is great for his and NXT’s visibility.”[Anonymous WWE source]
The Fan Response and Jenkins’ Viral Impact
Fan reaction to Hendry’s parody has been overwhelmingly positive, with many praising his seamless blend of humor and wrestling persona. Social media users have shared clips of the song alongside highlights from the pie incident, fueling further conversations about the storyline. The viral nature of Chelsea Green’s phrase and Hendry’s creative take demonstrates WWE’s growing emphasis on content that transcends traditional wrestling formats.
Wrestling commentators also speculate that this playful rivalry might bring increased attention to the upcoming NXT Gold Rush events. The mix of musical parody, comedy, and championship stakes creates a multi-faceted narrative appealing to a wide demographic of wrestling fans[2].
Looking Ahead: Can Hendry and Hail Upset the Champions?
The upcoming matches at NXT Gold Rush promise to be intense as Hendry and Hail look to dethrone the formidable Ethan Page and Chelsea Green. Hendry’s parody song has set the stage for a highly charged feud fueled by both competitive spirit and personal jabs.
Regardless of the outcome, Joe Hendry’s innovative use of music as a storytelling tool highlights his unique position in WWE NXT. As the championship feud unfolds, fans will be watching closely to see if Hendry’s vocal wit translates into victory in the ring.
Joe Hendry’s parody is a prime example of how modern-day wrestling increasingly blurs entertainment genres, combining sport, theater, and music. With NXT Gold Rush just days away, this storyline is shaping up as one of the season’s most entertaining narratives.
Stay tuned to WWE NXT and official WWE channels for all the latest updates and coverage.