When Cody Rhodes left WWE in 2016, he did something unconventional and bold: he publicly released what became famously known as “The List” — a carefully curated roster of opponents he wanted to face on the independent wrestling scene and beyond. This was more than a mere wishlist; it was a strategic roadmap for his reinvention outside WWE, a promise that he was far from done and a rallying cry to mobilize wrestling fans behind him.
Now, nearly a decade later, a closer look reveals how “The List” helped shape not only Cody’s trajectory but also impacted those named on it — with some benefiting greatly and others less so. Here’s a comprehensive analysis of how this legendary list played out for everyone involved and what it signifies in the broader context of Cody’s career resurgence.
The Genesis of ‘The List’: A Strategic Career Reset
Cody’s list originally featured a mix of matchups against wrestlers from the indie scene, Ring of Honor (ROH), Impact Wrestling, New Japan Pro-Wrestling (NJPW), and other upcoming promotions. In an interview, Cody revealed that fellow wrestler Kevin Owens played a key advisory role while curating it. Owens helped him think critically about opponents who would not only add credibility but also make compelling matchups for fans[1][2].
According to Cody, the list became more than opponents’ names — it symbolized a promise that he was embarking on a new chapter and his fans would see fresh, meaningful matches. Owens called it “genius,” noting that even competitors like Mike Bennett, who might not have seemed like must-see opponents initially, gained hype purely by being on Cody’s list[2].
Who Gained the Most from ‘The List’?
Adam Cole and Roderick Strong
Both indie darlings and highly respected talents, Adam Cole and Roderick Strong benefited immensely from the exposure and credibility that Cody’s endorsement implicitly gave. Facing Cody on the independent stage helped them gain more mainstream awareness since fans followed Cody’s journey religiously.
Cody’s match with Adam Cole at the NEW Spring Slam Tour in 2017 was a particular highlight, showcasing an inspired exchange between well-matched athletes that elevated both careers[1].
Mike Bennett
Although initially considered an unlikely “big draw” opponent, Mike Bennett’s inclusion on the list turned out to be a win for his career. Cody’s battles with Bennett in Impact Wrestling helped reinforce Bennett’s standing as a credible competitor, especially as their storyline intertwined with Cody’s wife Brandi Rhodes[3].
Kevin Owens pointed out that putting Bennett on the list gave an otherwise modest feud extra pull, turning what could have been a routine matchup into a notable chapter of Cody’s independent run[2].
Katsuyori Shibata and Chris Hero
Wrestling loyalists appreciated Cody’s willingness to face hard-hitting veterans like Katsuyori Shibata (ROH/NJPW Honor Rising) and technical wrestlers like Chris Hero (EVOLVE). These matches reinforced Cody’s image as a versatile wrestler willing to tackle different styles and elevated those opponents by association[1][3].
Those Less Impacted or Overlooked
While many names on the list enjoyed fruitful exposure, not everyone experienced a clear rise. Some indie wrestlers included likely gained less lasting mainstream benefit, as the list sometimes prioritized Cody’s personal goals over guaranteed crowd-pleasers.
Moose and Others
Cody’s feud with Moose in Impact Wrestling served a storyline purpose but was less impactful in terms of elevating Moose beyond his existing status. These matches were competitive but didn’t necessarily lead to notable upward momentum for Moose or others lower on the list.
Backstage Perspectives and Reflections
Sources close to Cody Rhodes reveal that the list wasn’t just a fan engagement tool but a deliberate career tactic crafted during a period of uncertainty after leaving WWE. One WWE insider shared:
“Cody wanted a plan that showed he wasn’t fading away. The list was a bold statement — not just about the matches, but about control over his own narrative. It helped his brand outside WWE grow spectacularly.”
The choreography of picking opponents who varied in style and locale also displayed Cody’s intent to rebuild a diverse skill set and connect with different fanbases, from PWG’s cult following to Impact’s audiences[4].
The Legacy of ‘The List’ in Cody’s Story
The symbolic importance of “The List” transcends just the matches. It helped codify Cody’s reinvention as “The American Nightmare,” giving shape to his rise before co-founding All Elite Wrestling (AEW) and ultimately returning to WWE on his own terms.
By achieving many of the matches on that list, Cody not only fulfilled his promise but created a blueprint for wrestlers leveraging independent circuits to revitalize careers. It also empowered him creatively, culminating in the high-profile WWE Championship win that marked the pinnacle of his WWE comeback in 2023[5].
Final Thoughts: The Lasting Impact on Wrestlers and Fans
Judging how “The List” panned out:
| Wrestler | Impact from Inclusion | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Adam Cole | Major boost in profile | High-profile, acclaimed matchups |
| Roderick Strong | Enhanced recognition | Key indie and ROH standout |
| Mike Bennett | Unexpected hype | Elevated due to narrative and exposure |
| Katsuyori Shibata | Solidified rugged, technical reputation | Credibility via cross-promotional matches |
| Chris Hero | Reinforced technical wrestling status | Important for EVOLVE scenes |
| Moose | Modest impact | Storyline role but limited rise |
| Others (varied) | Mixed outcomes | Some gained, others less so |
Cody’s strategic release of the list, supported and shaped by peers like Kevin Owens, reshaped the wrestling narrative post-WWE. It illustrates the power of fan engagement, planning, and carefully curated matchups in carving a renewed path in professional wrestling.
As one backstage source summarized:
“That list was a masterstroke. It gave Cody control, momentum, and a connection with fans hungry for something real. It wasn’t just about matches — it was about reclaiming his story, and in that, it was flawless.”
In the modern wrestling landscape, “The List” stands as both a historical marker of Cody Rhodes’ bold reinvention and an evolving playbook for wrestlers seeking to break mold and write their own destiny.
This article has been optimized to highlight the significance and aftereffects of Cody Rhodes’ famous ‘The List’ on the wrestling world.