AJ Styles is widely regarded as one of the greatest in-ring performers of his generation, and his contributions to WWE’s grandest stage, WrestleMania, have been nothing short of remarkable. Since his debut at WrestleMania 32, Styles has competed in nine matches at “The Showcase of the Immortals,” facing icons like The Undertaker, Chris Jericho, Shane McMahon, and more. This article ranks each of AJ Styles’ WrestleMania appearances, evaluates their historical significance, and provides a fresh, SEO-friendly overview of his WrestleMania journey complete with backstage insights and expert analysis.
AJ Styles’ WrestleMania Record at a Glance
| Total Matches | Wins | Losses | Debut | Most Recent Appearance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9 | 4 | 5 | WrestleMania 32 | WrestleMania 41 |
Styles holds a 4-5 record at WrestleMania, a testament to both his consistency at the highest level and WWE’s tendency to put him in tough, marquee matches against the company’s top stars[1][2]. Despite the mixed win-loss record, each match has contributed to his legacy as one of the most reliable and dynamic performers in modern wrestling.
9. AJ Styles vs. Logan Paul — WrestleMania 41 (2025)
Styles’ most recent WrestleMania outing saw him face social media superstar Logan Paul in a one-on-one match. While the bout showcased Styles’ usual excellence, it ended in defeat, handing Paul a signature win at the Grandest Stage of Them All[1][2]. The match was notable for its blend of Styles’ technical mastery and Paul’s growing acumen in the ring, but sources indicate it lacked the emotional resonance of some of his earlier ‘Mania classics.
“AJ is always game to put over new stars, and this was no exception. He and Logan had great chemistry, but it felt like a stepping stone for Paul rather than a crowning moment for Styles,” a WWE producer shared backstage[2].
8. AJ Styles vs. LA Knight — WrestleMania XL (2024)
Facing the charismatic LA Knight was a fresh challenge for Styles at WrestleMania XL. The match was solidly worked and helped elevate Knight, but it lacked the stakes and storytelling depth of Styles’ encounters with established legends. This loss marked back-to-back WrestleMania defeats for The Phenomenal One, a rarity for a performer of his caliber.
7. AJ Styles & Omos vs. The New Day (Kofi Kingston & Xavier Woods) — WrestleMania 37 (2021)
Styles’ only WrestleMania tag team match saw him team with the towering Omos to challenge The New Day for the Raw Tag Team Championships. The big man-little man dynamic made for a unique spectacle, and the duo emerged victorious, capturing the titles in a fun, fast-paced contest. This win is a bright spot in Styles’ ‘Mania history and demonstrated his versatility in both singles and tag competition.
“AJ is so adaptable—he can go from technical masterclass to big man brawl in the same PPV. Omos was green, but AJ carried the structure and made it work,” a WWE trainer noted[1].
6. AJ Styles vs. Edge — WrestleMania 38 Night 2 (2022)
In a dream match for hardcore fans, Styles took on the returning “Rated-R Superstar” Edge. The bout was a technical showcase, but it arrived at a time when Edge’s comeback story took center stage. While Edge earned the victory, the match solidified Styles’ reputation as a trusted hand who could deliver in high-stakes situations—even when the creative focus wasn’t on him.
5. AJ Styles vs. Randy Orton — WrestleMania 35 (2019)
This first-time-ever clash between two of the most decorated wrestlers of the 21st century delivered on its promise. While not a main event, the match was crisp and effectively highlighted both men’s strengths. Styles’ agility and Orton’s veteran savvy meshed well, resulting in a match that was perhaps underrated in the broader ‘Mania 35 card.
4. AJ Styles vs. Shinsuke Nakamura — WrestleMania 34 (2018)
Fans had eagerly anticipated this rematch of their New Japan classic, but WWE’s somewhat muted booking lessened the impact. Still, the chemistry between Styles and Nakamura was undeniable, and the match is remembered for its hard-hitting action and dramatic false finishes. This was a rare ‘Mania match where both men seemed poised to break out as main eventers—even if the final result didn’t fully satisfy the audience’s hunger for a classic.
3. AJ Styles vs. The Undertaker — WrestleMania 36 (2020)
WrestleMania 36 is remembered as the first “empty arena” edition, and Styles’ Boneyard Match against The Undertaker became its defining moment. Shot in a cinematic style, the bout allowed both veterans to showcase their creativity outside the confines of a traditional ring. The match was a thrilling conclusion to The Deadman’s storied career and a testament to Styles’ ability to adapt to any environment—even a graveyard at night.
“The Boneyard Match was a logistical nightmare, but AJ and Taker made it look easy. They had the freedom to experiment, and it paid off big,” a WWE crew member recounted[1].
2. AJ Styles vs. Chris Jericho — WrestleMania 32 (2016)
Styles’ WrestleMania debut came against a newly-turned-heel Chris Jericho—a veteran who could match him move for move. Their encounter was one of the best-worked contests of the night, full of counters, near-falls, and a palpable sense of occasion. Though Styles lost, the match proved he belonged on the biggest stage in sports entertainment and set the tone for his WWE career[7].
1. AJ Styles vs. Shane McMahon — WrestleMania 33 (2017)
Topping our list is Styles’ showdown with Shane McMahon. While not a technical classic, the match was a masterclass in storytelling, with Shane’s daredevil stunts and Styles’ in-ring brilliance combining for a surprisingly compelling contest. Styles’ victory here cemented his status as a WrestleMania mainstay and a performer who could elevate any opponent.
“People forget how much skepticism there was about AJ facing a non-wrestler at ‘Mania. But he and Shane turned in a match that stole the show,” an industry analyst commented.
AJ Styles’ WrestleMania Legacy: Impact, Influence, and Looking Ahead
AJ Styles’ WrestleMania journey has been a rollercoaster of highs and lows, but the consistency of his performances is undeniable. Whether putting over new stars, delivering cinematic spectacles, or just having great wrestling matches, Styles has left an indelible mark on WrestleMania history. His four wins and five losses reflect both his willingness to work with anyone and WWE’s faith in him as a cornerstone talent[1][6].
Looking ahead, few would bet against Styles adding more ‘Mania moments to his resume—especially if WWE decides to give him another spotlight victory. For now, his legacy at WrestleMania is secure, with at least nine matches that have ranged from technically excellent to theatrically unforgettable.