Background: Zayda Steel’s Rapid Rise from Indie Darling to WWE Prospect
Zayda Steel burst onto the professional wrestling scene in August 2022, quickly earning a reputation as an “indy standout” with a work ethic and charisma reminiscent of WWE’s own developmental system[3][5]. Over the next three years, the Arlington, Virginia, native became a staple in promotions like CZW, MLW, Beyond Wrestling, and even made waves in Japan with Dream Star Fighting Marigold[1][2]. Her in-ring ability, highlighted by a blend of striking and technical skill—her signature “I’m Prettier” inverted double underhook facebuster—made her a favorite on the independent circuit[2][3].
Steel’s breakout moment arrived in February 2023, when she captured the WOW Women’s Title in a four-way match, followed by a New Texas Pro Women’s Title win in late 2024[1]. Her rapid ascent was all the more impressive given her youth—she is only 22 years old—and relatively brief career[3][4]. By fall 2024, she had caught the attention of WWE, signing a development contract under the company’s WWE ID (Identification) program—a scouting initiative designed to identify and groom promising independent talent for potential main-roster futures[1][2].
WWE’s Approach and the End of the Road
Within WWE, Steel was primarily featured on the EVOLVE brand, a key part of WWE’s developmental pipeline, where she consistently delivered strong performances in the low-to-mid card[2]. However, despite a promising start, her run with the company was cut short as the WWE ID contract expired in early 2025. Sources close to WWE NXT suggest that while Steel impressed officials with her professionalism and in-ring work, a combination of timing and evolving roster priorities led to her departure.
A WWE insider commented, “She’s absolutely got the tools. Athletic, sharp in the ring, and she connects with the crowd. But with the influx of new signees and a push toward different styles, her spot just wasn’t there at the end.” While WWE’s loss, sources note that Steel’s value on the market has only increased since her release.
AEW Moves in: Sources Confirm Interest from Jacksonville
As soon as Steel became a free agent, All Elite Wrestling quickly joined the conversation. Fightful Select first reported AEW’s interest, and additional sourcing from within both AEW and the independent scene confirms that the company sees Steel as a strong fit for its women’s division, which continues to grow in prominence and depth.
According to an AEW executive who spoke on condition of anonymity, “We’ve had our eye on Zayda since her indie run, and her work in WWE only reinforced our belief in her potential. She’s got a presence, great fundamentals, and she’s still improving. She could be a real asset here.” With AEW’s women’s division increasingly spotlighting rising stars, and with the company’s recent emphasis on long-term roster building, Steel is seen as a logical next addition.
Steel’s Fit in the AEW Landscape
Steel’s versatility could be key to AEW’s plans. She has experience as both a singles and tag team wrestler, and her work in Japan and on the American indy circuit demonstrates adaptability across styles[1][2][3]. Her nickname, “The Real Deal,” is more than just a moniker—it reflects a reputation for reliability, toughness, and the ability to shine in high-pressure environments[5].
A booking agent familiar with AEW’s approach noted, “There’s always a desire for wrestlers who can elevate their opponents, and Steel has proven she can do that. Whether on TV, PPV, or Dark, she’s someone you can count on to put together a great match.”
Beyond her in-ring skills, Steel’s social media presence and connection with younger fans make her an attractive option in an era where audience engagement is everything. On platforms from X to Instagram and TikTok, she showcases a playful, confident persona that bridges her real-life energy to her wrestling character[3].
Competition for Steel’s Signature Heats Up
While AEW’s interest is real, they are not alone. Multiple major indie promotions, including GCW and DEFY, have expressed interest in bringing Steel on board as a featured star. Some within the business also suggest that TNA Wrestling, which has been aggressive in signing top free agents, might make a play for her. However, the lure of national television and a growing women’s division in AEW is likely to tip the scales in Tony Khan’s favor.
Sources close to AEW indicate that negotiations are in the early stages, with no formal offer on the table yet, but both sides are optimistic. “We’re talking, and it’s clear Zayda has options,” said a source with knowledge of the discussions. “But AEW’s platform and the chance to work with some of the best women in the world are major draws.”
What’s Next? The Future for Zayda Steel
For Steel, the next move could define the next phase of her career. Still just 22 years old, she is in the enviable position of being a sought-after talent with a proven track record and time on her side. Her brief WWE run only added to her mystique, and her exposure there—plus her consistent indie work—ensures she is a known quantity among wrestling fans.
If she lands in AEW, expect her to be featured prominently in both the flagship women’s roster and ROH’s developing system. “She’s the kind of talent you can build around,” said an industry analyst. “AEW can give her the spotlight she’s earned, and she can help raise the bar for the division as a whole.”
But regardless of where she signs, Zayda Steel’s story—from indie breakout to WWE prospect to one of the hottest names on the free agent market—is the stuff of pro wrestling dreams. As the business evolves, her next chapter is one to watch closely.
Backstage Buzz: Quotes and Context
A WWE official, speaking anonymously: “It’s tough to let talent like Zayda go, but right now it’s a matter of timing and roster space. She’ll do well wherever she lands, and honestly, I wouldn’t be surprised if she’s back in a WWE ring someday.”
An AEW source: “She’s the complete package—great look, great worker, and she’s just scratching the surface. Plus, she’s coming in with something to prove, and that’s always exciting for us and for the fans.”
A booking agent with ties to the indies: “Zayda is the real deal, pun intended. She’s the kind of signing that tells the locker room—and the fans—that AEW is serious about building for the future.”
Conclusion: The Next Big Move in Wrestling’s Women’s Division?
As the wrestling world watches, AEW’s pursuit of Zayda Steel could mark another significant step in the ongoing “women’s wrestling arms race” between major North American promotions. Her journey—from Virginia gyms to the bright lights of national television—is a testament to the opportunities available for young, talented wrestlers in today’s industry[3][5].
Will she join the ranks of AEW’s emerging stars, or will another promotion win the bidding? Either way, Zayda Steel’s future is poised to be one of the most interesting stories in wrestling in 2025. For fans and insiders alike, the waiting game is on.