The long-standing rivalry between AJ Lee and Saraya may be reigniting after both superstars hinted at a possible renewed feud through recent social media interactions. This development has piqued the interest of WWE fans eager to see a compelling revival of one of the most memorable storylines in recent women’s wrestling history.
A Social Media Spark Reignites Memories of a Classic Feud
The spark for this speculation began when the USA Network’s Instagram commemorated the eleven-year anniversary of AJ Lee and Saraya’s iconic championship clash. This prompted the two former WWE Divas Champions to engage in a friendly back-and-forth on social media, reminding fans of their dynamic and often intense on-screen battles. AJ Lee sent a nostalgic message asserting, “Never over, freaks and geeks and frenemies for life,” signaling that their story isn’t quite finished[4].
AJ Lee, who returned to WWE in September 2025 after a decade-long hiatus, quickly made her presence felt by winning her first match back. Meanwhile, Saraya has been making waves after her split from AEW earlier this year and has expressed openness about a WWE return, fueling speculation that the rivalry could resume inside the squared circle.
AJ Lee’s Return and Saraya’s WWE Ambitions
AJ Lee’s return to WWE was met with excitement, given her influential role during her initial run and her championship success. Her comeback hints at WWE’s interest in tapping into nostalgic rivalries while blending them with current storylines. Saraya’s departure from AEW and statements about missing WWE’s locker room, particularly the camaraderie with fellow women wrestlers, suggest she is seriously considering a return to WWE programming[1].
During a recent Busted Open Radio interview, Saraya admitted watching AJ Lee’s return moments “with a big smile,” indicating both respect and fondness for her former on-screen rival. She said, “I miss being in the locker room, I miss being around my sisters. WWE is doing amazing things right now.” However, Saraya also noted she wants to spend much of 2025 pursuing other projects before stepping back into the ring[1].
Inside WWE: Could The Feud Be Planned for 2026?
According to a WWE insider familiar with current creative directions, backstage conversations suggest the WWE is exploring ways to reintroduce AJ Lee and Saraya to the audience, potentially rekindling their feud with fresh stakes to attract both nostalgic viewers and newer fans.
“WWE recognizes the gold mine in reviving classic rivalries, especially when both talents still have significant fan followings and in-ring ability,” said the source. “AJ and Saraya bring not only history but depth — a complex mix of rivalry and friendship. The timing looks right for WWE to build a storyline around that nuanced relationship.” Though nothing is officially confirmed, plans for a slow build toward a feud in early 2026 are reportedly being discussed[4].
The Evolution of Their Story: From Rivals to Friends and Back?
AJ Lee and Saraya’s history in WWE was unique, evolving from fierce competitors to complex allies. Their relationship was characterized by intense matches, on-screen drama, and genuine chemistry appreciated by fans and critics alike. Their storylines extended beyond the ring, making their interactions layered and unpredictable.
As Saraya told Busted Open, their relationship was never black and white, describing it as “freaks and geeks and frenemies for life.” This hints that if WWE pursues this angle, it could be more than just a simple feud potentially blending past tensions with moments of alliance, creating a storytelling dynamic rich with emotional stakes.
Fans’ Response and Market Impact
WWE’s official social media posts celebrating past matches and anniversaries, coupled with the wrestlers’ own participation in online exchanges, have triggered a resurgence of fan interest. Social media buzz and viewership metrics from AJ Lee’s recent appearances display strong engagement, underlining the potential success of reintroducing this storyline[4].
A WWE marketing consultant told Wrestling News, “Legends like AJ and Saraya bring authenticity and credibility to WWE’s women’s division. Their feud offers a chance to tap into cross-generational fan bases, which is invaluable for WWE’s ongoing viewer retention efforts.”
What Could This Mean for Women’s Wrestling in WWE?
Reigniting the AJ Lee vs. Saraya storyline could also serve a broader purpose within WWE’s women’s division. By merging legacy stars with current talents, WWE can showcase the evolution of women’s wrestling from the Divas era to the current generation emphasizing athleticism and compelling character work.
It may also open doors for other veterans contemplating returns and create storyline opportunities to elevate emerging stars by associating them with proven, respected talents like AJ Lee and Saraya[1][4].
Looking Forward: What to Expect Next?
While Saraya continues to balance her personal projects and AJ Lee has already made several impactful appearances, WWE fans eagerly await confirmation of their feud’s return. Whether this potential rivalry unfolds as a full rivalry or a nuanced partnership with occasional conflict will depend on WWE’s creative vision.
For now, fans can watch for:
- Upcoming WWE promos or segments referencing their past,
- Possible tag matches featuring AJ Lee, Saraya, and rising stars,
- Social media teasers hinting at storyline developments,
- Official WWE announcements targeting special events like Royal Rumble or WrestleMania 42.
Final Thoughts
The tantalizing hints dropped by AJ Lee and Saraya have reignited one of WWE’s most beloved rivalries, suggesting that this compelling story is far from over. With both stars active and engaged with the WWE universe, and backstage support apparent, the prospect of a renewed feud in 2026 adds excitement to WWE’s women’s division.
As one WWE insider summarized, “If anyone can tell a story that’s equal parts friendship and rivalry, it’s these two. WWE fans will want to be front and center when this chapter opens.”