WWE Hall of Famer The Undertaker has spoken out in defense of the new format of his popular podcast Six Feet Under, which now features his wife and fellow WWE Hall of Famer Michelle McCool as co-host. The Deadman addressed recent fan criticism regarding McCool’s role on the show, urging listeners to be patient and appreciate the evolution of the podcast.
Michelle McCool Joins Six Feet Under, Bringing a Fresh Dynamic
After a hiatus since March 2025, Six Feet Under returned under the WWE umbrella with a revamped format. Michelle McCool was introduced as co-host alongside The Undertaker, replacing the previous co-host Matthew Lyda, a friend connected through the apparel brand Nine Line. Both McCool and The Undertaker, who are WWE Hall of Famers, bring unique wrestling insights and personal chemistry to the podcast, contributing to its fresh direction.
The relaunched podcast is now available on WWE’s official YouTube channel, signaling a strategic partnership involving WWE, Fanatics, and their podcast ventures. This new phase places Six Feet Under alongside other WWE-hosted podcasts like those by Cody Rhodes and Stephanie McMahon, expanding WWE’s reach in the digital audio space[3].
Critics React to the New Co-Hosting Dynamic
Some fans initially voiced skepticism about Michelle McCool’s involvement, expressing concerns that the podcast’s original tone and depth might suffer. Critics suggested that McCool’s presence diluted the show’s focus on wrestling lore and insider stories, questioning whether the podcast could maintain its edge.
In response, The Undertaker, known for his composed yet formidable persona, addressed these criticisms candidly in a recent episode. He asked critics to “relax and enjoy the ride,” emphasizing that the show is evolving to include new perspectives and is intended to be enjoyed as a broader entertainment experience rather than only a traditional wrestling podcast[2].
Adding Broader Appeal and Future Plans
Michelle McCool complements the podcast by bringing fresh ideas, including plans to feature interviews with stars from outside wrestling, such as NFL athlete George Kittle and musicians like Travis Scott, Jelly Roll, and Snoop Dogg. This ambitious roster aims to expand the podcast’s audience beyond wrestling purists and into mainstream pop culture[3].
Behind the scenes, WWE executives reportedly believe this strategy will invigorate the franchise, making it more appealing to a wider demographic. According to a WWE insider, “Michelle’s addition isn’t just about changing the format, it’s about leveraging her star power and connection with Mark [The Undertaker] to build something unique that appeals to both wrestling fans and casual listeners alike.”
The Undertaker and McCool: A Power Duo Beyond Wrestling
Both McCool and The Undertaker are not only Hall of Famers but also share a compelling personal story that enriches their on-air chemistry. Their candid discussions range from their in-ring careers and health challenges to life behind the scenes at WWE. For instance, in one episode, The Undertaker opened up about a serious health scare he faced around WrestleMania time, showcasing a vulnerable side rarely seen by fans[4].
Their synergy is palpable, blending humor, nostalgia, and genuine conversation that provides fans with an intimate glimpse into two of WWE’s most iconic figures. This dynamic is a distinct shift from the more straightforward, single-host wrestling podcasts and signals WWE’s broader effort to diversify content delivery.
Fan and Industry Reception Moving Forward
While some purists continue to debate the merits of the new format, initial engagement data points to increased listenership, especially among younger and more diverse audiences. Wrestling journalist Dave Johnson commented, “This is a smart move by WWE — leveraging star power and blending wrestling with wider culture conversations. Michelle’s presence adds new energy, and Mark’s storytelling remains the cornerstone.”
Sources close to WWE have noted that the company plans to sustain this podcast model, with possible spin-offs or special editions involving other WWE Hall of Famers and celebrities. There is a consensus backstage that Six Feet Under with The Undertaker and Michelle McCool is positioned to become one of WWE’s flagship podcasts in the years ahead.