In a moment WWE fans dreamed about, AJ Lee returned to WWE for the first time in a decade during the September 5, 2025, episode of SmackDown in Chicago, her hometown. The appearance electrified the crowd, who erupted with chants and cheers as the former Women’s Champion ran to the ring to aid her husband, CM Punk, in a heated confrontation against Seth Rollins and Becky Lynch.
A Triumphant Homecoming in Chicago
AJ Lee’s return was not only emotional but strategically timed. The energy inside the arena was palpable as Seth Rollins introduced Becky Lynch, the Women’s Intercontinental Champion, for the main event. Lynch immediately antagonized the Chicago crowd, sparking boos and boos—a classic heel move. When she attacked CM Punk, who was there to support his hometown, the arena ignited with Punk’s iconic “Cult of Personality” chant, signaling the fans’ roaring approval.
Just when tensions seemed to peak, AJ Lee appeared unexpectedly, rushing to Punk’s aid and confronting Lynch directly, much to the delight of the Chicago faithful. Her presence alone sent a clear message that a new chapter in this feud was about to begin[1][2].
The Feud That Sparked AJ’s Return
This reunion didn’t come out of nowhere. The feud between CM Punk and Becky Lynch had been brewing since Becky notoriously cost Punk the World Heavyweight Title at the WWE Clash in Paris 2025 by attacking him post-match. Tensions escalated on SmackDown with Seth Rollins and Becky Lynch aligning against Punk. AJ Lee’s interference on behalf of her husband clearly signals WWE’s intent to develop a high-profile mixed tag team storyline leading into the upcoming Wrestlepaloza event on September 20[1].
What’s Next? Wrestlepaloza Showdown Looms
Fans and analysts alike expect AJ Lee to participate in a tag team match alongside CM Punk against the formidable team of Seth Rollins and Becky Lynch at Wrestlepaloza 2025. Wrestling insider sources have hinted that this return is more than a one-time appearance. A WWE insider explained, “AJ’s return is designed to elevate this rivalry into one of the biggest storylines this fall. The chemistry between these four performers is undeniable, and WWE is banking on that to deliver a must-see event in Chicago.”[1]
AJ Lee’s Impact and WWE Legacy
AJ Lee was one of WWE’s most charismatic and trailblazing female stars during her original run, capturing the Divas Championship three times and earning acclaim for her impassioned promos and in-ring skills. Her return resonates not only as a nostalgia moment but as a potential launchpad for renewed prominence in WWE’s women’s division.
Her collaboration with CM Punk also adds a unique dynamic to WWE’s storytelling, blending real-life chemistry with storyline drama, a formula that has historically captivated audiences.
Backstage Buzz: The Fans and Wrestlers React
Backstage, the buzz about AJ Lee’s return has been overwhelmingly positive. A WWE crew member shared on condition of anonymity, “There’s an electric vibe with AJ back. Everyone knows how much she means to this city and the company. This isn’t just a cameo—it’s a reminder of her lasting impact and what she still brings to the table.” The palpable excitement from Chicago’s crowd only underscores the perfect timing of her comeback[1].
Social Media Frenzy and Fan Reactions
AJ Lee’s surprise return sent social media into a frenzy. Fans flooded platforms with clips and posts celebrating her shock reappearance, while wrestling analysts dissected the implications of this storyline shift. The buzz has only increased anticipation for Wrestlepaloza, making this a trending topic in professional wrestling circles worldwide[2].
Summary: A Storyline Loaded With Potential
AJ Lee’s return on SmackDown has reinvigorated CM Punk’s current storyline and provided a fresh layer to the rivalry with Seth Rollins and Becky Lynch. Against the backdrop of Chicago’s enthusiastic support, this segment showcased why WWE continues to lean on its legacy stars to create compelling television.
With Wrestlepaloza on the horizon, the stage is set for AJ Lee and CM Punk to make a monumental impact—and Chicago is ready to witness it live.
AJ Lee’s return marks arguably the biggest surprise of WWE programming this year, brilliantly combining nostalgia, star power, and local pride for one unforgettable night. Fans will be watching closely to see how far this storyline goes and if AJ Lee’s WWE journey has truly only just begun.